Which is sad, because American Dreamz is a not at all a bad film. It might have done better as it does have three of four fairly large stars and a simple enough premise — a Bush-like President (Dennis Quaid), a calculating karoake singer (Mandy Moore) and a would-be terrorist (Sam Golzari, not one of the large stars, though he should be) all wind on the set of an American Idol-like television sensation hosted by a borderline-evil Brit (Hugh Grant) who, if I ever bothered to watch reality television, I would probably recognize as a stand-in for that Simon Cowell guy.
I guess somewhere between the mixed reviews, the oddly unimpressive trailers, and the whole issue of funny terrorists five years post 9/11, the public decided to look elsewhere this weekend. It actually might have helped if rightwingers had bothered to attack it.
Still, I found this movie consistently funny and I encourage folks to consider checking it out sooner or later. Like a labrador puppy that really wants to be a fox, this movie is way too nice to be a real satire, but it is funny and intriguing in its essential niceness.
This movie portrays a world in which a would-be terrorist is a sweetheart, George W. Bush is nothing but a kindly, well-intentioned dunderhead, and even a Dick Cheny/Karl Rove amalgam (Willem Dafoe, finding his inner straightman) and Simon Cowell have their likable sides. It’s a fantasy.
Some of this may be genorisity of spirit and it may also reflect some good cinematic influences. Writer-director Paul Weitz earned my eternal sympathy when I read how he once put some friends to sleep by trying to make them watch The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp (I can relate…though I usually put my friends to sleep just by talking about movies).
I don’t know whether Weitz was even contemplating the level of complexity of a Pressberger/Powell or Jean Renoir ensemble film in which everyone “has their reasons,” but I like to think he might have enjoyed a brief delusion of grandeur. (You gotta have a delusion to make a delusion come true!)
I do know that there’s enough material for a miniseries here…and I really think American Dreamz might have more worked better in that format. There are enough outstanding comic performances here to power several good hours of HBO level television. Apart from acting institutions like Quaid, Dafoe, and Grant, Sam Kolzari generates real sympathy and suspense as the shmoe/terrorist. But, just as important, it has one of the strongest comedy benches in recent memory.
It’s a digression, but it was especially great to see Shohreh Aghdashloo (who broke my freaking heart in House of Sand and Fog) and John Cho (who broke none of my body parts but was nevertheless very, very good in both Harold and Kumar Go to White Castle and Better Luck Tomorrow). And, while they didn’t have any scenes together that I recall, I’d pay to see young Cho and fiftyish-Aghdashloo together in a film. Harold and Nazneen Go to Zankou Chicken? Works for me.
Anyhow, I really hope that American Dreamz picks up a little in its second weekend, or at least does better later on. I like movies that try.